November 1, 2020
Gr 3-6-The majority of this series presents a simple regurgitation of well-known facts. However, the layout, which features minimal text with lots of images, framed text, and brights colors, may engage reluctant readers. There are some hits and misses with the more problematic parts of American history. The section covering Mount Rushmore in Monuments and Memorials could have noted the controversies surrounding its placement. The White House emphasizes Donald Trump's Twitter habits: "President Donald Trump is a big fan of Twitter. He has sent out more than 100 tweets in a single day!" This is accompanied by a photo of a smiling child standing next to Trump. In a speech bubble, the child says, "Way to go with the tweets, Mr. President!" This ignores the derogatory nature of Trump's tweets and how he uses his platform to spread misinformation. However, the series treats Native Americans with respect. Their individual names and tribes are identified, as well as their contributions to the colonies' success. VERDICT If you are looking for something new, look elsewhere. However, the flashy layout could attract reluctant readers.
Copyright 2020 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
December 1, 2020
Grades 3-5 Four iconic elements of the U.S. government are spotlighted in the X-treme Facts: U.S. History series (6 titles), presenting each subject through a well-rounded mix of historical information and interesting trivia. The Presidents takes a scattershot approach to profiling the men who have occupied the nation's highest office, focusing largely on the names that will be most familiar to young readers. Each double-page spread tackles a different aspect of the topic, with pages composed of an introductory paragraph and a series of captioned illustrations and colorful infographics. Often, speech bubbles are superimposed over a photo or image, turning historical pictures into humorous scenes that reinforce a given fact. Each volume contains a glossary, as well as a DIY craft project. While the text is entirely uncritical of American history and leadership, the dynamic (albeit somewhat sloppy) design, and engaging approach--leading readers to broad understanding through an accumulation of intriguing factoids--will draw in reluctant young historians.
COPYRIGHT(2020) Booklist, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.